SEO for Agencies: How We Actually Ranked Our Own Site

SUMMARISE WITH AI
Opens the selected AI with this article's URL pre-filled. You choose to send.

Search “SEO for agencies”, and you will mostly find two things: ranked lists of agencies to hire, and roundups of tools other agencies use. Neither tells you how an agency actually ranks itself.

This is that. It is the exact approach used to build and rank this site, broken into three parts: how the strategy comes together, why the keyword targets look nothing like what a keyword tool would recommend, and the build decisions behind the site itself. None of it is specific to SEO. It applies to any agency selling expertise rather than a product, whether that is recruitment, law, real estate or marketing.

How We Approach SEO for Our Own Agency

The process is the same eight-step approach we use for client sites, just pointed at this one: understand the business, audit the site, check competitors, then build a bespoke strategy before touching content, links, or ongoing optimisation.

The audit stage runs on the same tools recommended to clients:

  • Screaming Frog for the technical crawl.
  • Google Search Console and GA4 for performance data.
  • Semrush and Ahrefs for keyword and competitor research.

“Expert tip: Semrush’s Authority Gap tool is particularly useful for agencies. When assessing authority, use referring domains as the primary metric rather than relying solely on an authority score. Agencies are typically highly focused on building authority and backlinks, so this helps clearly demonstrate the difference in backlink strength between your site and your competitors. ”

There is no reason to hold a client site to a lower standard of evidence than your own.

Two decisions from that process matter more than the rest once you are ranking your own agency:

  • No “busy SEO”: An audit does not need forty action items to be useful. It needs the two or three fixes that are actually blocking rankings. Chasing every warning a crawler flags wastes time on issues that will never move a page.
  • Depth over breadth: Instead of a handful of broad pages, such as one generic services page and a contact page, the site runs on dozens of narrow ones, a page for each industry served, from recruitment agencies to healthcare to SaaS, and a separate page for each city, from Sydney to Newcastle to the Central Coast.

That structural choice isn’t accidental, and it isn’t padding. It is the entire keyword strategy, which is worth explaining properly.

Why We Chase Intent, Not Volume

A keyword tool will tell you “SEO agency” gets searched thousands of times a month, and “SEO for recruitment agencies” gets searched a handful of times. On volume alone, the first term wins every time. It is also almost useless.

“SEO agency” “SEO for recruitment agencies”
Monthly searches Thousands A handful
Who is actually searching it Students, competitors, job seekers, browsers Someone who already knows they run a recruitment agency
What the page has to do Convert a crowd with no shared need Convert a reader who has already half-decided

A keyword’s value is not its search volume. It is how many of the people searching it are actually ready to buy, multiplied by how well the page they land on matches what they were looking for.

The Lifetime Value Math Behind It

A single retainer client here runs $1,000 to $2,500 a month. Kept for even six months, that is $6,000 to $15,000 from one enquiry. That number, not search volume, is what actually decides whether a page is worth building.

  • A narrow, high-intent page does not need thousands of visits to justify itself. It needs to convert one or two of the ten or so people a month who search it, because a single client at that value covers the effort many times over.
  • A page built around a generic term might pull in five hundred visits and convert nobody, because none of those five hundred people has told you who they are or what they need.

That is also why the site is not built around one page trying to rank for everything. Each industry page and each city page exists because the client walking through that specific door, a Brisbane tradie, a Canberra business, a recruitment agency,  is worth building for individually, even if the keyword behind it barely registers on a keyword tool. We document the results in our case studies.

Before building a page around any keyword, the better question is never “how many people search this.” It is:

“If ten people searching this became enquiries, would even one of them be worth it?”

Web Development Strategies Behind the Site

None of the above works if the site underneath it is slow or hard to crawl. Site speed and crawlability come before content or link building on every project, including this one, because a fast, well-structured page search engines can actually read is a strict precondition for the rankings that follow.

A few build decisions make that possible:

  • The platform: The site runs on WordPress, chosen deliberately because it needs to support many near-identical industry and location pages. Building a new page for a new suburb or industry has to be fast, not a fresh development cycle each time.
  • Cannibalisation control: Running dozens of similar pages side by side creates its own risk, where two pages end up competing against each other for the same search term instead of each ranking for its own. This is managed through deliberate site architecture and internal linking, so a page about SEO for real estate agents and a page about SEO for lawyers never quietly fight each other for the same ranking.
  • Hands-on implementation: Client reviews on the site specifically call out help with actually building and maintaining a website, not just auditing one from the outside. A technical audit that ends in a list of recommendations somebody else has to implement is only half useful.

Working directly with the build, whether that is fixing what a crawl throws up or setting up a new site from scratch, is what actually closes the gap between finding a problem and fixing it.

The Bottom Line

The strategy, keyword targets, and site build are not three separate decisions. They are one decision looked at from three angles: build pages worth building, for people worth converting, on a site that can actually deliver them.

  • Want it handled for you? White Label SEO covers the same process end to end.
  • Want to run it yourself? SEO Coaching is built for exactly that, with someone checking your work.

Yes. None of the reasoning here is specific to SEO agencies. Any agency that sells expertise rather than a product, recruitment, law, real estate, insurance, benefits from the same logic: a handful of specific, high-intent pages will out-convert one broad page every time, and the client lifetime value math works the same way regardless of what the retainer is for.

It varies by competition and how established the site already is. Still, the pattern holds regardless of timeline: a narrow page with almost no competition tends to start ranking and converting well before a broad page fighting for a competitive head term does. Patience is still required, just less of it.

Not if each page is built around a genuinely different audience and written for it specifically, rather than the same page repeated with a city or industry name swapped in. A page for a Brisbane tradie and a page for a Canberra business need different examples, different local context, and different framing, not just a different heading. The risk is real when pages are templated without enough genuine difference between them, which is a separate problem from cannibalisation and needs genuinely distinct content, not just internal linking.

The same lifetime value math from above decides it. If a realistic retainer value and a plausible conversion rate for that audience add up to more than the page costs to build and maintain, it is worth doing, even at ten searches a month. If an industry or city has no realistic path to a retainer client, the page is not worth building, no matter how easy it would be to rank.

No. The keyword and page strategy decides where the effort goes, not what replaces it. The same eight-step process still includes content optimisation, outreach and link building, and ongoing adjustment. Getting the page targets right means the content and links that follow are built for pages that were actually worth the effort in the first place.

Key Takeaways

“Effective SEO isn’t about chasing rankings. It’s about building a search strategy that creates sustainable visibility, meaningful traffic and measurable business growth.”

Aidan

CEO, Aidan Coleman

Turn SEO Insights Into Real Growth

Ready to put your SEO strategy into action? Get expert guidance from Aidan Coleman SEO to improve visibility, attract the right audience and build sustainable organic growth.

Related Post

Scroll to Top